It’s not enough to simply add comments to your site and expect a community to emerge. If you want great discussions to happen on your site, you need to participate in the conversation. But how?

In this post, we put together five easy ways you can interact with readers in the comments. We incorporated some of our favorite examples for each idea that showcase publishers who know how to do it right. If you have examples of successful tactics for engaging readers from your community, share it in the discussion below.

1. Responding to questions

One of the easiest ways to engage with readers is to answer their questions. There’s nothing more discouraging than having your question ignored, so get in the habit of answering questions from readers. If you don’t know the answer, mention someone on your team who might be able to jump in to respond.

Over at Nom Nom Paleo, author Michelle Tam is quick to reply to readers’ inquires for advice on various ingredients and cooking methods. As a result, readers regularly post questions on her latest recipes.

Reporters at local news site Berkeleyside respond to questions from readers to help them stay informed on the issues and developments that impact the local community.

2. Asking for feedback

Comments offer a great opportunity to obtain feedback and insights from readers to help you create more interesting and relevant content. Asking readers for their thoughts lets them know that you are actively listening to what they have to say, which is key to forming a lasting relationship with your audience.

Besides the countless hours they spend rigorously testing products, product review website Wirecutter regularly solicits feedback from readers to help improve their guides. Here’s one recent example:

3. Welcoming first-time commenters

Make first-time commenters feel right at home by welcoming them to the community. This increases the likelihood that they will stick around and keep coming back to participate in discussions.

To identify first-time commenters, check out the user’s commenting history by visiting their Disqus profile or searching for their most recent comments on your site using the Moderation Panel. If you have a Disqus Pro plan, sort the Community Members table by “First Engagement Date” to find these users in just a few clicks.

When readers post their first comment on SpoilerTV, the site’s founder jumps in to welcome them aboard and point them to helpful resources:

4. Informing readers about the site’s comment policy

One of the most common questions we hear from commenters is about why their comment was removed. We created the Comment Policy feature to make it easier for publishers and readers to be on the same page about how comments are moderated.

Set the tone for a new discussion by posting a comment that reminds readers about the site’s guidelines and featuring it at the top of the discussion. This ensures the comment will be the first thing readers see when they arrive in the discussion. Here’s one example from a moderator at ScienceNews:


Moderators are people too! They have a tough, but essential role in any community. Don't be afraid to remind readers of this, like KTVZ's moderator does in the example below.


5. Showing appreciation for someone’s comment

Readers visit your site for the content, but they stick around for the conversation and community. When you show your appreciation for their comments, they may reciprocate by participating more regularly. Any bit of acknowledgement can go a long way, whether it’s an upvote or a direct reply. Here are two examples from Birth.Movies.Death. and Man Repeller that show you how easy it can be:

💬 How do you engage with readers in the comments?

We just shared five of our favorite ways publishers can interact with readers in the comments. We want to hear yours now! As a reminder, we read every comment posted on the blog. Finally, it goes without saying that we appreciate any feedback you have to contribute 😉